[Coke] c: HEAD e 00:40
committable6 [Coke], ¦HEAD(bac79ca): «»
06:20 hurufu joined 06:57 hurufu left 06:58 hurufu joined 07:22 hurufu left 07:24 hurufu joined 08:00 samebchase left
Geth rakudo/lizmat-120: b643fc19bc | (Elizabeth Mattijsen)++ | src/Perl6/bootstrap.c/BOOTSTRAP.nqp
Fix conflict resolution snafu
10:06
rakudo/main: 2e48cbdd67 | (Elizabeth Mattijsen)++ (committed using GitHub Web editor) | src/Perl6/bootstrap.c/BOOTSTRAP.nqp
Streamline some bootstrap parts (#6915)

  - use constant lookups where possible
  - use lowered lexicals instead of attribute accesses
  - rewrote some tight loops in nqp without needing return
11:29
11:37 rakkable left, rakkable joined 12:06 samebchase joined
lizmat m: my Int $ = "foo" 13:03
camelia Type check failed in assignment; expected Int but got Str ("foo")
in block <unit> at <tmp> line 1
lizmat c: my Int $ = "foo"
committable6 lizmat, ¦my: «Cannot find this revision (did you mean “nom”?)»
lizmat c: HEAD my Int $ = "foo"
committable6 lizmat, ¦HEAD(2e48cbd): «Type check failed in assignment to $ANON_VAR_2; expected Int but got Str ("foo")␤ in block <unit> at /tmp/a_pHWt0tOg line 1␤␤ «exit code = 1»»
lizmat I guess "anonymous variable" would be better than $ANON_VAR_2 13:16
14:56 hurufu left, hurufu joined 15:33 hurufu left 15:34 hurufu joined 16:28 hurufu left
[Coke] * [ ] [List::Util](raku.land/zef:lizmat/List::Util) – Fail, Bisected: [4a08d67](github.com/rakudo/rakudo/commit/4a...29b176630) 16:36
lizmat checks
[Coke] whoops. That's from 2026.09 to NEW=bac79ca - (should have been from .11) 16:37
but still.
I don't see a 'not ok' or 'failed' in the output 16:38
lizmat tests fail with: 16:41
Undeclared routine:
xx used at line 20
[Coke] aye 16:43
lizmat c: HEAD use v6.*; rand xx 20
committable6 lizmat, ¦HEAD(2e48cbd): «===SORRY!=== Error while compiling /tmp/6ayy6rlBVT␤Undeclared routine:␤ xx used at line 1␤␤ «exit code = 1»»
[Coke] weird that didn't get caught until blin. 16:44
lizmat the underlying issues appears to be with "use isms "Perl5". without that commit 16:49
use isms "Perl5"; rand xx 20;
shows the same error
so it was a long-standing error, uncovered by making: use isms "Perl5" the default 16:50
c: 2026.11 use v6.*; rand xx 20 16:51
committable6 lizmat, ¦2026.11: «»
lizmat c: 2026.11 use v6.*; dd rand xx 4 16:52
committable6 lizmat, ¦2026.11: «(0.695727392250533e0, 0.6227640335835958e0, 0.18078815612448962e0, 0.19504815530478803e0).Seq␤»
lizmat c: 2026.11 use isms "Perl5"; dd rand xx 4
committable6 lizmat, ¦2026.11: «===SORRY!=== Error while compiling /tmp/3OWXKR5Fjt␤Undeclared routine:␤ xx used at line 1␤␤ «exit code = 1»»
lizmat bisectable6: 2024.01 use isms "Perl5"; dd rand xx 4
bisectable6 lizmat, Using old=2024.01 new=HEAD in an attempt to do what you mean
lizmat, Bisecting by output (old=2024.01 new=2e48cbd) because on both starting points the exit code is 1
lizmat, bisect log: gist.github.com/ac44ab695e741e3230...5203c22d90 16:54
lizmat, (2024-11-22) github.com/rakudo/rakudo/commit/a9...b4dced35bc
lizmat bisectable6: 2018.09 use isms "Perl5"; dd rand xx 4
bisectable6 lizmat, Using old=2018.09 new=HEAD in an attempt to do what you mean
lizmat, Bisecting by output (old=2018.09 new=2e48cbd) because on both starting points the exit code is 1
lizmat yeah, looks like it was an issue since "use isms" was introduced 16:55
bisectable6 lizmat, bisect log: gist.github.com/7a4aeec81b283facb7...731c34361b 16:56
lizmat, (2024-11-22) github.com/rakudo/rakudo/commit/a9...b4dced35bc
lizmat I'm starting to have half a mind to rip out all of the isms / obs stuff 17:18
in any language level
and instead make "use isms" an external lib that doesn't do anything 17:27
ShimmerFairy I wanted to find out more about what this 'isms' thing is, and the docs website only gives a short summary with one or two P5 examples. Roast also has very little for P5 isms, and nothing at all for C++.
lizmat in 2018 the discussion was that it was too soon to remove the Perl related error messages 17:28
but I think we can say that the influx of Perl programmers into Raku is pretty small
Geth rakudo/main: 95aa98b153 | (Elizabeth Mattijsen)++ | src/Raku/Actions.nqp
Revert "RakuAST: make "use p5isms/c++isms" default in 6.e+ (#6928)"

This reverts commit 4a08d6742093bb66311525d008be5f829b176630.
It breaks e.g. using the `xx` operator with `rand`, which is a common idiom.
17:32
lizmat ab5tract [Coke] hope it's ok I pushed to main directly
I'd be in favour of ripping out all .obs and isms stuff in any language level 17:33
c: HEAD class A { has $! } # feels to me that should be an error 17:38
committable6 lizmat, ¦HEAD(2e48cbd): «»
lizmat what's the use of a nameless attribute ? 17:39
c: HEAD use isms; class A { has $. } 17:41
committable6 lizmat, ¦HEAD(2e48cbd): «===SORRY!=== Error while compiling /tmp/l_rhL1b7uY␤Cannot declare an anonymous 'has' scoped variable␤at /tmp/l_rhL1b7uY:1␤------> use isms; class A { has $.<HERE> }␤ «exit code = 1»»
ShimmerFairy Warning about Perl 5 isms was arguably pointless once people stopped expecting Perl 6 to actually be the next major version, and *definitely* pointless once the name changed to Raku. Perl is just another language one might be familiar with before learning about Raku. 17:43
lizmat c: HEAD my $a := my Int $ where * > 0; $a = -1; say $a 17:45
committable6 lizmat, ¦HEAD(95aa98b): «-1␤»
lizmat c: HEAD my $a := my Int $b where * > 0; $a = -1; say $a
committable6 lizmat, ¦HEAD(95aa98b): «Type check failed in assignment to $b; expected <anon> but got Int (-1)␤ in block <unit> at /tmp/8Uy3JBoPc8 line 1␤␤ «exit code = 1»»
lizmat c: HEAD my $a := my Int $ where * > 0; $a = "foo"
committable6 lizmat, ¦HEAD(95aa98b): «Type check failed in assignment to $ANON_VAR_2; expected Int but got Str ("foo")␤ in block <unit> at /tmp/bqvSm91PZa line 1␤␤ «exit code = 1»»
lizmat I think we need some cleanup in that area
19:17 hurufu joined 19:28 hurufu left
patrickb B 21:43
2026.11 binaries are out 21:44
lizmat patrickb++ 22:31